« Dershowitz Threatens To Sue Hasidic Child Sex Abuse Whistleblower, Asks DA To Recuse Himself From Criminal Case | Main | Charges Against Sam Kellner Finally Dropped »

March 07, 2014

British Jewish Leaders Continue To Cry Anti-Semitism, Lie, To Protect Shechita

Chuck-roastThe truth of kosher slaughter is far more cruel and far more ugly than Orthodox rabbis of all stripes and Jewish communal leaders are willing to admit. But rather than fix the problems with with commercial shechita, these leaders instead choose to lie (or, perhaps more charitably, repeat lies uttered by others).


Stephen Pollard, the editor of the venerable Jewish Chronicle, Britain's oldest Jewish newspaper, wrote an op-ed published in the London Times today that contains both misstatements of fact and an outright untruth.

Pollard cites a very questionable Israeli study done by a kosher food industry insider and his colleague. Neither are animal biologists or veterinarians. Neither are actually qualified to reach the pro-shechita conclusions they reached. Both are Orthodox. One, Ari Zivotafsky, is also an Orthodox rabbi.  Zivotafsky undergraduate degree is in electrical engineering and his Ph.D. in in biomedical engineering. His colleague Rael Strous is a psychiatrist. Both study brain science.

The paper Zivotofsky wrote was published in the Meat industry journal Meat Science.

Pollard could have found all this out in less than five minutes. He obviously either chose not to do that or intentionally misled Times' readers.

Pollard's deception, however, does not stop there. It continues, and among the claims he makes is this:

"…The recommended standard is a maximum 15-second delay between stunning and killing. That is rarely met. With shechita, the slaughter method is itself the stun, so there is no delay at all.…"[emphasis added]

This is absolutely false. In cattle, it can take two minutes for cattle to be rendered unconscious. If the cut is not correctly done – and this is alarmingly common – it can take even longer, as the 2004 Agriprocessors scandal proved.

Besides these egregious examples of twisting facts, Pollard's main tactic is to take examples of mis-stunning and compare them to examples of the best shechita possible – an old trick used by the Jewish community in the US in the past. Take a great shochet, remove all time pressue and all disturbing factors, have him kill one or two small cattle, and compare his results to standard non-Jewish stunned slaughter done on a production line at full speed. Shechita looks pretty good that way, especially when you compare it to results of stunned slaughter done with decades old "knockers" the captive bolt guns that propel a steel bar at extremely high speed into the animals brain, rendering it unconcious and serious brain damaged.

Those old captive bolt guns misfired far too often and their desogn allowed for easy operator error. A mis-stunned animal is supposed to be immediately re-stunned, but agitated operators using those old guns could easily fail to do that second stun properly, and the result in some cases was horror. Those sufferiing animals were, at least in the US, supposed to be immediately shot in the head with a rifle – after workers moved out of danger.

But today's stun guns rarely misfire and are designed to reduce operator error. Consequently, there are much fewer incidents of mis-stunning.

To his credit, Pollard doesn't cite the old data on mis-stunning a vice president of the Board of Deputies of British Jews, Jonathan Arkush, misused yesterday on the BBC. But he still essentially lies.

As I noted yesterday, Arkush lied about stunning, citing findings drawn from extremely old studies that were based on techniques and equipment that have not been used in years – sometimes in many decades.

"Animal welfare organisations have shown that pre-stunning fails to stun in between nine and 31% of cases. When an animal is 'miss-stunned' it suffers enormous pain and distress,” Arkush said, failing to note that modern stun guns misfire closer to the 1% to 2% range.

Arkush also failed to note that kosher slaughter has its own error rate that is about the same or slightly higher than the rate of mis-stunning.

Arkush also failed to mention any of the many kosher slaughter scandals with horrific inhumane slaughter documented on videotape that have taken place worldwide over the past decade, from Agriprocessors in Postville, Iowa in 2004 to South America, France, Israel – where the most recent of several scandals took place a few months ago – and New Jersey, where inhumane Jewish ritual slaughter was documented earlier this year.

These types of misstatements or lies will not save shechita. In the end, they doom it, just as false cries of anti-Semitism doom it.

But most of all, what dooms shechita are scandal after scandal after scandal involving inhumane slaughter at the most kosher meat slaughterhouses in the world, from Iowa to South America, to France, to Israel.

Watch this video from Agriprocessors, then the largest glatt kosher slaughterhouse in the world, located in Postville, Iowa:


Now, here's Pollard's shameful article. Please click to enlarge:

Ritual slaughter is quicker and kinder

Related Post:

Will Pro-Shechita Lies Ward Off A Ban On Kosher Slaughter?


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

"It's the most humane method killing an animal" -- the biggest lie that I've ever heard since I've been involved with "frumkeit". It has no basis in science or reality.

It is only my opinion, but I am saying this as someone who has killed hundreds of animals by various methods -- 20-gauge shotgun is my favorite -- including schechita of poultry.

It is the "shechita" "process" that "mattirs" the animal to us (cf. Rambam); not the actual killing of the animal. How "humane" the process is has nothing to do with it.

Should it be a humane process? Personally, as a "frummer yid", I think so.

Theese rebbes would rather die then conform to the prevailing standards,insane is what they are.

We, as jews, have been lied to as well.

We were always told and taught that shechita was the most humane method.

A shochet told me, when I questioned him, that the animal thrashing about was just a muscle twitching reaction after death.

How can he explain to me where in this video, the poor animal clearly stands up and walks off? Dead cow walking?

The bull@&$! Has been revealed, it is all crap, and a con on the religious world.

On top of it, what was seen before as the best , most humane method, is now seen as the cruelest.

This is not a good look jews.

This will increase anti-semitism, and racism.

We must pressure the rabbis to stun before shect.

We must do this by boycotting kosher meat, until they adopt the more humane method.

Eat fish and veggies until then.

If enough people do this, they will be forced to act, or the whole kosher meat industry will falter.

@jancsibacsi Personal question: Where are you from? Me: My father: Walking distance from the Chasam Sofer, which makes me third generation (in America) from him. My mother: France (the Aquitaine) up to Henry the VIII (that I can verify) when he had pretentions that he was King of England, Ireland and France; then America -- 11th generation.

Rabbis lie? Next you'll tell me priests bugger little boys

We must pressure the rabbis to stun before shect....If enough people do this, they will be forced to act, or the whole kosher meat industry will falter.
Posted by: BeenThereDoneThat | March 07, 2014 at 03:48 PM

This is (well-intentioned but) wishful thinking; it's not going to happen. You've got more chance of getting Reform Rabbis to perform metzitzah b-peh at a bris than of getting traditional posqim to permit stunning prior to slaughter.
The closest they will get is to allow a bullet to the animal's head immediately (within 3 to 5 seconds) after shechitah, as is done in some countries.

This is nearly as big a lie as "There's a benevolent God."

It is an unnecessary lie because the purpose of shechita was to avoid pain - a quick painless death - perhaps at the time it was invented it was but the bottom line is it's not any more. The principle dictates a change in the practice and most the establishment is too cowardly too own up to this and say from now on schechita needs to change to uphold the principles in the torah. Very sad.

They lie and deceive because they are too lazy or stupid to change their ways. They'd rather subject an innocent animal to pain and anguish rather than own up to their lies. Kashruth is cruelty. KOSHER meat tastes different because the animal is unduly stressed during the kill.

++This is nearly as big a lie as "There's a benevolent God."

Posted by: Jeff |+++


the most shameful part of todays collection of ignorant and impotent rabbis is that the lesson of the talmud is that halacha CAN and SHOULD be changed to reflect reality. There are numerous paths which can be taken that would permit stunning that would be consistent with existing halachic principles. instead they render halacha obsolete, immoral and backwards while using lies in its defense.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment


FailedMessiah.com is a reader supported website.

Thank you for your generous support!




Please Scroll Down Toward The Bottom Of This Page For More Search Options, For A List Of Recent Posts, And For Comments Rules



Recent Posts


Tip Jar

Gelt Is Good!

Tip Jar

FailedMessiah.com is a reader supported website. Please click the Donate button now to contribute.

Thank you for your generous support!

Tip Jar

Gelt Is Good!

Tip Jar


Comment Rules

  • 1. No anonymous comments.

    2. Use only one name or alias and stick with that.

    3. Do not use anyone else's name or alias.

    4. Do not sockpuppet.

    5. Try to argue using facts and logic.

    6. Do not lie.

    7. No name-calling, please.

    8. Do not post entire articles or long article excerpts.

    ***Violation of these rules may lead to the violator's comments being edited or his future comments being banned.***

Older Posts Complete Archives

Search FailedMessiah

Lijit Search


FailedMessiah.com is a reader supported website.

Thank you for your generous support!




FailedMessiah.com in the Media

RSS Feed

Blog Widget by LinkWithin