« Kellner Attorney Calls Forward Journalist "Lazy, Shoddy, Dishonest" – And Proves It | Main | Haredi Mother Who Intentionally Starved Her Child, Sparked Massive Riots, Breaks Plea Deal, Prosecutors Say »

November 25, 2013

Brooklyn D.A. Gives Probation-Only Sentence To Chabad Pedophile With 8 Page Charge Sheet

Haredi handcuffs black suit 2Outgoing Brooklyn D.A. Charles J. Hynes gave a Chabad pedophile with an 8-page charge sheet that includes second degree incest a 10-year probation-only sentence.

Please click to enlarge.

Case summary and sentence:

Yosef Y Donin case summary_Page_1

8 Pages of criminal charges against Donin:

Yosef Y Donin case summary_Page_2


Yosef Y Donin charges_Page_1

Yosef Y Donin charges_Page_2

Yosef Y Donin charges_Page_3

Yosef Y Donin charges_Page_4

Yosef Y Donin charges_Page_5

Yosef Y Donin charges_Page_6

Yosef Y Donin charges_Page_7

Yosef Y Donin charges_Page_8

Jewish Community Watch's Wall of Shame  contains the names and photos of both convicted and accused pedophiles – some of whom have never been criminally charged or civilly sued. But even though Donin's name was released by the D.A. in July (as the D.A.was preparing for what turned out to be his failed reelection bid), JCW does not have Donin's name of its Wall of Shame. And that is especially odd because it has Donin on its site, named in the NY Post article JCW reprinted that lists the names of 46 convicted child sex abusers whose names were released by the D.A. And it's even more odd because Donin lives in Crown Heights.

Here's JCW's Wall of Shame in its entirety – without Donin:

Wall Of Shame_Page_1

Wall Of Shame_Page_2


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Given that the frumma usually don't report frum on frum crimes to the police, to have this many indictments, there must be a staggering amount of other victims or offenses.

It's not too bad.
10 years is a long time. You can be certain he'll violate the terms of his probabtion at some point, then Thompson can lay down the hammer.
Provided he doesn't get corrupted by Satmar and the hassid bloc anyway

i guess with hynes kicked out of office his pal seewald will not be able to pick and choose his perps.

Does the DA actually give the sentence in these situations or is this recommended to the judge?

JCW has its own criteria of who they list. Part of that is if the perp is willing to agree to and keep certain conditions, they don't list them. Maybe Donin is complying with them or doesn't meet their criteria for some other reason.

Seewald didnt put Yossi Dunin (his other spelling) because he "only" raped his daughters. He wasnt caught rapeing any other child. Even though he was a bus driver for many years at Oheli Torah boys school. The same school that pedophile Yossel Raices worked in.

Square hole, What is the source of your information? That is quite an outragous statement.

Does anyone know what Yaakov Bryski, pictured above (and much praised by Yossi post assaults) is doing now? Was he ever charged?

To Singemalt

You can contact Seewald. It is known that he has specific guidelines to be put on his web site. Since Yossi Dunin wasn't caught with other children only his own Seewald no reason to put his picture on his site.
I spoke to a driver at the yeshivah as to why he is no more working. I was told that when he realized he was about to get busted he decieded to quit his bus driving job and blame it on the fact that he was working to hard and wanted a raise. He then went on to work for Rabbi Kotlarsky and drove the daily bus that goes to the Ohel. Now, since he was found guilty (plea bargained he has no job and his bus license was revoked. You can verify this by calling the school and speak to Sholom Rosenfeld @ 718-774-5050 that's if he will speak about it now that the story camer out.
My info is not some story being told at the water cooler....

Put a Square, I have no reason to doubt that what you are saying is true to this extent. If someone doesn't meet the criteria, they don't get listed.

I'm more questioning the reasoning that you are ascribing behind the criteria that you mention. (I have no personal knowledge as to the criteria btw.) You say that "Seewald (has) no reason to" and "because he "only" raped his daughters". You are implying that Seewald places less importance on abuse among family members.

I would imagine that there are many reasons behind Seewald's criteria and that if Donin doesn't fit he won't be listed, no matter how egregious his actions.

I am sure that the rape of a family member is extremely appalling to Seewald. To say that Seewald doesn't list someone that doesn't meet the criteria, because it's not important to him is quite a strong accusation.

Aside from all that the critera are not made public for good reason. So, if you happen to know some of the criteria, why would you post it on a public site?

He was found by the Court to be:
Sex Offender Rating Level 2

Level 2 moderate risk of repeat offense

Ten years probation? Maybe the Lubavitch rabbi that went to court trying to end the 10 year probation of another Level 2 sex offender, will offer again to go to court with this one to have his probation ended early. In the meantime if he goes to the shul where he is the rabbi, he can be assured of getting full honors!

Believe me - now that this has become public - he won't be getting any honors anywhere. Unfortunately, it's his kids that will suffer the most as no one wants to marry in to such a family.

+++Believe me - now that this has become public - he won't be getting any honors anywhere. Unfortunately, it's his kids that will suffer the most as no one wants to marry in to such a family.

Posted by: Proud Chabadnik | November 26, 2013 at 12:37 PM+++


Yes, really.

Just like all the other molesters listed on JCW - no one's honoring them and no one's lining up to be meshadach with their kids.

Molesting someone else's kid is bad enough but banging one's own daughter!?! That's really low!

Posted by: Proud Chabadnik | November 26, 2013 at 02:42 PM

What about Mendel Tevel?

Mendel Tevel's name is dirt. The only ones in his corner is his immediate family and his in-laws.

I don't know mendel tevel but I did work for his in laws in Beverly hills California. I was 18 at the time.
I quite the place because his so called "rabbi" father in law, Hertzel Illulian tried to sleep with me a couple of times, he came in and told me he has to stay the night at my house, and asked if he can sleep and caudle with me. I said no but he kept trying.
He was told mendel tevel is a pedophile before he married his daughter but got him to marry his daughter anyways because they are both pedophiles. what type of sick minded father will allow his daughter to marry one, he ruined his daughters life.

I hope they do a investigation on him.
also he is a shady business man. in his "JEM CENTER" RICH PEOPLE DO COMMUNITY SERVICE HOURS. and he lets them buy him out with money. he also steals from people and I can vouch for that anytime.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment



FailedMessiah.com is a reader supported website.

Thank you for your generous support!




Please Scroll Down Toward The Bottom Of This Page For More Search Options, For A List Of Recent Posts, And For Comments Rules


Recent Posts


FailedMessiah.com is a reader supported website. Please click the Donate button now to contribute.

Thank you for your generous support!


Comment Rules

  • 1. No anonymous comments.

    2. Use only one name or alias and stick with that.

    3. Do not use anyone else's name or alias.

    4. Do not sockpuppet.

    5. Try to argue using facts and logic.

    6. Do not lie.

    7. No name-calling, please.

    8. Do not post entire articles or long article excerpts.

    ***Violation of these rules may lead to the violator's comments being edited or his future comments being banned.***

Older Posts Complete Archives

Search FailedMessiah


FailedMessiah.com is a reader supported website.

Thank you for your generous support!



FailedMessiah.com in the Media

RSS Feed

Blog Widget by LinkWithin