« VIDEO: Neturei Karta Tells Al Jazeera Zionism Has Created "Rivers Of Blood" | Main | Rabbi Matisyahu Solomon Gravely Ill »

March 15, 2012

VIDEO: The Chabad Rabbi And The Prostitute

Rabbi Yisroel Noach Kamenetsky, Chabad shaliach in Altai Barnaul, FSUA Chabad shaliach in the Former Soviet Union has a pornographic liaison with a prostitute caught on videotape.

Rabbi Noach Kamenetsky of Barnaul, Altay, FSU caught on videotape having sex with a prostitute – while wearing his yarmulke.

Here's the link but BEWARE! The video is pornographic and very explicit.

Here's the link on Chabad.org to his Chabad House:

Rabbi Yisroel Noach Kamenetzky's Chabad House Listing

And here's what you get (as of 9:00 am CDT today) when you click that link:



Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

I havent looked at it since you advise against it. But couldnt it be his wife. These lubs like to show everyone what theyre doing. Tsnius is not in their Torah. More important to tell everyone that they're human as well. How better than to show it on film.

Thanks for the porn link.

But couldnt it be his wife.

No. It clearly isn't his wife.

I can't understand why the rabbis are against unfettered use of the internet.

This is too much this guy is a sex addict and with a yarmulka on his head while having sex tottal moron.

Shmaryah!!

I can't believe you stooped to such a low level, with your hatred towards (personal) chariedim,
Did this guy's deeds cause any harm to anyone except for himself?

Isn't it - a chariedi leading a double life- something you are advocating for?

This is not more than you making him pay for a sin he did כלפי שמיא!!

What's the point מה בצע of sitting in someones spilled blood and having a ball plachking in it?!!

You have no feelings-even if it means,plastering him all over the internet- to someone who wears a black hat.

(No,I did not see the video, and I plan to see it)

I would suggest removing this as there is nothing here for the 'greater good', no lessons to learn, nothing to improve upon, just one person being weak, and will do much harm.

No. It clearly isn't his wife.

True, if it were his wife they would be using the bedsheets with a hole in it.

Not sure internationally shaming this guy was the right thing to do.

(No,I did not see the video, and I ""DON'T"" plan to see it)

Posted by: מרדכי סטמר | March 15, 2012 at 09:46 AM

Lubavitchers are not the only chasidim and charedim visiting prostitutes. This guy just got caught on tape.

Who taped it? For what purpose? Blackmail? Extortion?

he is clearly not enjoying it and is exhibiting tremendous mesiras nefesh in his effort to be mekarev the young lady. i take back anything negative i may have said about chabad shluchim. they go lifnim meshuras hadin.
olam haba HERE I COME!!!!!!

im sure rabbi lazar has him on flights to israel immedietly

"I can't believe you stooped to such a low level, with your hatred towards (personal) chariedim,
Did this guy's deeds cause any harm to anyone except for himself?"

Maybe his wife! He obviously doesn't use protection with the prostitute. Does he come home and have sex with his wife also? Could wifey be pregnant and pass VD or aids to her baby?

I hope the prostitute got combat pay for servicing this hairy dude.

Hey Chevra,

Maybe he thought he was only doing kiruv.

She probably taped it for security reasons, e.g., if she got robbed by someone, there would be physical evidence.

I also wonder whose idea was it to post it on the Internet? Some people will do anything to make a buck. Maybe she got angry because he did not give her a tip.

Moral of the story is:

Rabbi said: Keep in view three things, and you will not be tempted to sin: know what is above you—an eye that sees and an ear that hears, and all of your deeds are written in a book.

Had Rabbi witnessed this tape, he probably would have added, "video-tape."

The Russian heading over the video said:

"The main Hasidic rabbi Yisroel Noach Kamenetsky Altai Barnaul appeared five years ago and immediately became the most popular "wealthy man" for local heifers on call.

The secret of success is seen in this chic videfragmente main thing is not to shoot during the "dialogue" with a pile of parishioners - the traditional Jewish hat, and then extend the time in Barnaul brothel is endless!"

When compared to the behavior of his peers, this rabbis behavior should be applauded.
Having consensual sex with an adult female is better than raping little boys (at least in my book).

Poor fella didn't realize Putin sees everything (looks like it was a hidden camera he didn't know about).
Maybe he was just checking to see if the rumors that her "area" looks like The Rebbe's beard were true?

(I'll leave it to others to wonder how Shmarya found this and was doing at the time!)

which of these 3 is most offensive and inappropriate?

1. whats the big deal ? meshichists have needs too.

2. was it the rebbes official psak that you wear a kippah during this type of kiruv?

3. can she be brought to the ohel for yechidus?

the caption in Russian says it's the "secret of his success"

just goes to show you that everyone is human, even the ones with beards and yarmulkes - the problem is that they place themselves on a pedestal as if they were better than the rest of us.

his father is the the chief rabbi of deneppeprotsk and is oneon the worlds wealthiest russian rabbis

Of course you should report it. These Lubs are all at it. They call it kiruv, a big mitsva. As it happens this is the only thing the Torah calls kiruv. 'tikrvu lgalos erva'. They miss out the 'lo' at the beginning. This will bring moshiach or in their language he will 'wake' up (not surprising). Why didnt he keep his tsitsis on or did he even offer her a pair.

Some become Chabad by birth, some by conversion, and some by injection.

The rabbi seems to be kosher only from the waist up. If he loses his job over this, he could become a superstar in the porno business, so long as he wears his yarmulke and beard, and plays the Hava Nagila. Maybe he could use the same melody for Hava N'gia.

Shabbtai Tzvi would be so proud of him. He used to have parties like this in his time too!

Wow, he's hung like a Shetland pony!

What a high class blog this is! A yardstick by which others should measure up to.

I am a bit surprised he did not try to "lain tefillin" with her, the black leather would have added an interesting element to his escapades. Besides, he would be doing a mitzvah!

Yet another practitioner of "the loving rabbi" syndrome!

Goes back to the bad old days days of Zimri and Kosbi and the daughters of Midaian who prostituted themselves at the expense of the Israelites!

Was he "porking" her?

That was one great Hava Nagila and example of ohev es habrios (making love to the creatures) to bring them close to the Torah (zu-hee the inner Torah) which is the Rebbe Schneersons' Hasidus.

Whats next....a video of Dovid Hamelech and Batsheva.....Please take this down...we are all human and make mistakes.

I am a little surprised he did not have a picture of the Rebbe on the wall, but he at least wore his yarmulke, which goes to show even when a Jew commits a sin, he is still God-fearing(well, sort of . . .)

He evidently does not believe the Rebbe is everywhere watching him like God.

How are the Russian Chabad rabbis going to spin out of this? They will probably say she was his wife. But the Russian website says he has been doing this type of thing for many years.

Plenty more where this came from.

The more the haredim/frumiks scream against tayvos haguf and tsnius the more they are letting us know how sick they are, how stuck they are.

We are witnessing the collective meltdown of a totally repressed, self-hating society.

Their end can't come fast enough.

Then, when they are gone, maybe their mythical moshiakh will truly come.

Mind you, using a prostitute isn't a victimless crime (trafficking, anyone?), but I don't see what point it serves.

its how babies are made ; a new and future disciple for sholom rubashkin and his zealous sect.[in the making]. maybe one day the baby will write a letter to otisville "in praise of s m r "

At least he's not a fag

Not sure internationally shaming this guy was the right thing to do.

Posted by: Garnel Ironheart | March 15, 2012 at 09:55 AM

He is chabad, our sworn enemy as such it is our moral obligation to do whatever it takes to bring them down.

Commandment #||: "If thou violateth commandment number five thou shall not wear thine yarmulka."

Or, one could say that this philandering hiloni at least keeps one halacha, ve-tavo alav bracha.

This proves that 'chabad' is spinning out of control since the rebbee [obm] died.Many messianics deny that they are part of this crazy movement to get money from people. They defraud many people by NOT admitting that they are part of this yellow flag avodoh zarah group. When confronted if they are part of this messianic cult their silence is deafining.

I did not watch the video yet (but sure will when I get home :) but am curious if the rebitzen did BMP on him?

(No,I did not see the video, and I ""DON'T"" plan to see it)

Posted by: מרדכי סטמר | March 15, 2012 at 09:46 AM
Oy gevalt you should see it , just for the gevaltige shikses performing a sex act on a heiliger yid its a big mitzva the shiksa is perserving his marriage it is a gevaldige mitzva she is a tzadeikes beyond a shaddow of a doubdt.

Commandment #||: "If thou violateth commandment number five thou shall not wear thine yarmulka."-
I gree with you the wearing of a yarmulka while having an erection is a groisen aveire usser mideraise.

DA,

Chabad is categorically opposed to MBP because of the Kabbalah, or so I have heard from many people over the years who are Chabad.

We are witnessing the collective meltdown of a totally repressed, self-hating society.
litvish
You are 1 billion per cent right it is exactly the way you wrote no question about it

I hear he is contacting SxCheck for "papers" so he can get work in the adult film industry. They have a glowing testimonial on their web site:
"Get tested by SxCheck. Period. These guys are the pros. -Ron Jeremy"

:)

is father is the the chief rabbi of deneppeprotsk and is oneon the worlds wealthiest russian rabbis

Posted by: the lion | March 15, 2012 at 10:27 AM

This is an out right LIE it is another family- and even if it were the truth why is this your business to say?? are you so holly??

I hope he left the door open so it won't yichud,

And during Sefirah does she know no music

Not sure internationally shaming this guy was the right thing to do.

Posted by: Garnel Ironheart

PUH-LEEZ!!

where do you think the money for this came from? the lowlife undoubtedly gets donations from well meaning marks who he convinces that said donation will bring them a piece of gan-eyden. instead he buys himself a little slice of heaven right here on this earth. he deserves every bit of public shame. HE SHAMED HIMSELF.

dear sheker

i beleive you are mistaken

kamenetsky deneppeprost has had no statment about his families behavior

sheker if your so concerned what say you about kamenetskys behavior before you lecture about anything else

No,I did not see the video, and I ""DON'T"" plan to see it)

Posted by: מרדכי סטמר | March 15, 2012 at 09:46 AM
Oy gevalt you should see it , just for the gevaltige shikses performing a sex act on a heiliger yid its a big mitzva the shiksa is perserving his marriage it is a gevaldige mitzva she is a tzadeikes beyond a shaddow of a doubdt.

Posted by: jancsipista | March 15, 2012 at 11:42 AM


Thanks for the chochmas zkainim.

sheker if your so concerned what say you about kamenetskys behavior before you lecture about anything else

Posted by: the lion | March 15, 2012 at 12:08 PM

I say if it were YOUR son or brother, would you want someone running to volunteer shameful information about him?

@ The Lion

you have no clue what you are talking about.
There is absolutely no relation between the two Kamanetsky's.

I hope he left the door open so it won't yichud,

And during Sefirah does she know no music

Posted by: Fact


excellent.

this could definitely lead to mixed dancing.

Bas Melech -what about the chuhma of a toiridge learned yid.well i guss when it comes to sex all chuhmas are butel.

i'm going to be 'dan lekaf zechus' and assume he first went to the ohel and got the rebbes OK.

maybe he never had metzitza b'peh performed at his bris and was afraid he wasnt really jewish. she offered to do it for less than a mohel. no story here. move along.

Sheker,

If the rabbi hid his identity, put on a disguise, took off his yarmelke, his behavior would still be bad, but at least he took the steps to show a bit of modesty. How can he walk into a whorehouse with a yarmelke and not expect people to gossip or create a scandal?!

In all these FM stories about the Haredim, they all point to the same problem: They behave as though the world is indifferent to what they do. The world is justifiably holding the Haredim and Hasidim to a higher ethical standard than both of these groups are willing take on in their lives.

It's a lot easier to make a big deal about Kashrut or Shabbat observance. It's a lot easier to throw stones at the Reform or the Conservative movement for their heretical ideas and practices. It's much harder to deal with real life morality, which is frankly far more ethically challenging.

What is Noah Kamenetsky going to say to his wife and religious community, who erroneously placed their trust and respect in him?

Look, temptation is everywhere. There is a fine line every human walks--but for Noah, this was not the first time he had done this. He was a regular customer. Even Rev. Jimmy Swaggard had the common sense to hide his identity--but not Noah.

Haredi and Hassidic rogues behave like true atheists--they live without God and without a conscience for the people they harm.

What

Actual pornography, a new low for this site.

Pulicly shaming someone for a private indescresion is horrible. This guy should clearly lose his job, and not be allowed to work as a religious leader anymore, but why should his private indescresion be publicised?

If Shmarya was caught on tape having gay sex with a male prostitute (I don't know if he does or doesn't swing that way, this is purely theoretical) he would be the first one to scream that it was a private indescresion and should not be publicised.

What he did to the prostitute, Chabad is doing to Judaism.
I didn't watch, though. Can anyone tell me where they put the usual pic of the rebbe?
Wait, don't tell me...

abcdef,
You've definitely got some anxiety going there over gay sex.
Relax, we're friends here. And anonymous. You don't have to prove anything or hide your feelings.

@ Chicago Sam | March 15, 2012 at 12:43 PM

i loved the comment until you wrote...

Haredi and Hassidic rogues behave like true atheists--they live without God and without a conscience for the people they harm.

while atheists indeed live without god, as do theists (though only the atheists realize it), to say that they live without a conscience for those they may harm is ridiculous and untrue. it plays into every malicious stereotype foisted upon them by those who would like to pass themselves off as owning the moral high ground and as a means to keep others from joining their ranks.
as a conservative jew, i would think you would be more sensitive to this kind of thinking since your group is spoken of in similar terms by the frummies.
i can assure you that many atheists are highly moral and view things in humanistic terms which are far superior morally and ethically to much of what is taught and followed by bible people.
statistics also bear this out. the percentage of atheists in prison is far below their numbers in the population, and the countries with the highest rate of atheists have the lowest rates of murder and rape.

Shmarya's point is that this is the rebbe's fault for sending shluchim to bad places like 42 st.

he is being maaleh all the nitzotzos...

this tape was released 3 weeks ago, rabbi lazar fired him as soon as he saw it.

He has been in Israel since.

Truly a sickk man to say he is a rabbi and collect money from people and then use it to buy himself a hooker...

Even the best of people stoop to a low low level..

Look at the bright side '' at least he diden't molest a little kid'' instead he got caught with a hooker.

The only one who was really zoche to have beeaahs hamoshiach was Chana Mushka.

When a molester gets exposed everyone is like why couldn't he just get a hooker ect...

So instead of bashing this man...

I think the rest of the comments should be GOOD JOB NOAHC

Thank you for taking your desires out on a hooker instead of a child!!

We are proud of you

Oh I wouldn't say schtupping a prostitute on video is so bad, all things considered. A Chabad rabbi cum porno king actually humanizes the fiends.
And think of the punny possibilities it gives us.
Chabad House of Ill-Repute?
Whorebad House?

how many children does he have, who is his wife

Where is his family now

Let's not be too hasty here.
Perhaps he was auditioning for the part of Rabbi Eleaza ben Durdia in a Purim play.
(Avoda Zarah 17a)

Posted by: מרדכי סטמר | March 15, 2012 at 09:46 AM


It's interesting that both you and abcdef seem to have no issue whatsoever with a Rabbi /Shliach committing adultery with a prostitute and making a video of it in the process. (No I have no intention of watching the video). Your only issue is with Shmarya.
You call it a private indiscretion. It became public once the video was produced.

You really are willing to excuse almost any action committed by a Hasid, it seems. I doubt you'd be so forgiving if he was caught eating a cheeseburger.

One word:Cruel cruel cruel dancing on spilled blood.Proves again that HATE is what FM is all about.

Yet another two-faced hypocrite who won't condemn a chillul HaShem by a hassidic rabbi.

after talking to chabad rabbis i am told he may only be a distant relative to kametsky in deneppeprost

however they say that rabbi lazar and kamentestky are warning all shluchim that if they have done acts like this they should leave very queitly

there was a song written about this.

"lookin for moshiach in all the wrong places"

It's Fake! Shame on you

.Proves again that HATE is what FM is all about.

Posted by: Deremes

yes, many of us hate hypocritical lowlifes. many of us hate two-faced fraudsters. we hate when deluded messiahnists induce gullible people into giving them money under false pretenses. many of us hate the fact that some people choose to dress in a way that lets everyone know theyre super-jews and then act in a way that brings shame on all jews.

if you DONT hate these things theres something wrong with you.

Its just like the Haredi response to Leib Tropper's egregious behavior." It's a private matter.. it's a fake."

And they wonder why so many people reject everything they say, even when they tell the truth.

Shmarya Rosenberg
What a loser you are . Do you still live with your mom ? Seriously, check yourself into a mental hospital.

"Did this guy's deeds cause any harm to anyone except for himself?"

oooooooh! but u can't say that, mr satmer, when we are all in the same boat, the shmuck is drilling a hole in the boat and we all sink with him! no?

Just got this email

EMERGENCY: We were just notified that Hatzalah's emergency lines are down.

You must call 718-998-8775 if you have an emergency, please forward this accordingly.

@ The Lion,

You still dont know what you are talking about...someone tells you "he MAY be a distant relative" and you post it as fact?
you better off saying he is related because both of their great-great grandfathers were Avraham avinu, (now thats a fact)

Nobody can prove that it aint his wife!

ah-pee-chorus-although i am not an MO ubermentch like you still i hate hypocrites.And in no way am i defending his actions.A person like this should not preach to other people how to be a better Jew.
My issue here that a person is being exposed being belittled,defamed for his stupid sinful actions.Yeah i know he should of known better and not do it.
YOU can not get enough of this.
YOU are ecstatic about this.
YOU are out to prove the world that observant Jews are lowlifes and hypocrites,fine. But YOU don't care that at the same time a person is being buried alive.
YOU don't care that his kids(if has any)will look at their father differently now.
YOU don't care about anything just to show the world what frum Jews are all about.And that is even at the expense of a private person.
As an ubermentch MO YOU should be ashamed of yourselves how low YOU stooped.

Here is my take. Had there not been a tape of this and the chance that the world would see the undeniable truth i wonder if he would have been fired. Infortunately what forces thesr people to get fired is more of the fact that the power mongers will look bad than the actuall questionable moral act

Shmarya Rosenberg
What a loser you are . Do you still live with your mom ? Seriously, check yourself into a mental hospital.

Posted by: Jack | March 15, 2012 at 01:43 PM

His mom died.

That being said and considering that he is not married makes for one lonely individual. He lives alone so we can surmise that this video will be played many times. Listen, you make due with whatever is at "hand"

This video is a LIE. I did not watch it, nor will I but it is clear that it is NOT his natural hair. His hairline does not show, he is wearing a wig and his head is completely covered.

Deremes:

He should have thought about his kids before shtooping a prostitute.

Obviously he didn't care about his wife

i can say one he is a healthy guy it shows on his getting up and his standing firm erection:))

deremes-

first of all i'm not MO, other than by social associations.
you said ".A person like this should not preach to other people how to be a better Jew."

the problem is that charedim have shown time and time again that they will ignore many despicable and sinful actions as long as they can keep it quiet. its clear that the ONLY way to insure that the vile movement known as charedism will do the right thing is when they are shamed into it occasionally
through measures such as this. if there existed a video of kolko or mondrowitz or any other charedi abusers actually engaged in the act, then even the pathetic charedim would have forced them out of their positions and spared many others from being victimized. and while i dont equate going to a prostitute with abusing kids, its still outrageous behavior for a clown promoting ortho judaism as his profession.
i am ecstatic when jerks like this are exposed. and when you wrote, "even at the expense of a private person." ....

he is NOT a private person. he is a representative by his own choice of chabad, and a face for judaism.

theres nothing "low" in delighting at the fall from grace of someone who deserves it. just as there is nothing wrong with being pleased when a guy like madoff is caught and sufers the consequences of his actions. justice is a beautiful thing. i love it more than any other concept i can think of.

Way better than the Tropper and Eisenstein sex tapes.

There are many category in porn; Black, Asian, Indian, Latin. Now we can have a Haredi sex category. 

The question is if Satmar will get their own category or they will be subcategorised under incest and pedophilia. 

Has anyone thought of the possibility that he may have been forced to do this?

Blackmail? Or a kidnapped relative? Etc?

There is a huge criminal element in Russia

Surely this deserves further investigation.

Proves once again what i have been saying again and again,Shmaryah this piece of human garbage,is nothing but a dirty self hating Nazi bastard,and had he lived 68 years ago during the holocaust,this filthy rat would have been the chief KAPO in Auschwitz,and with a smile on his dirty face would have chased his brothers and sisters into the gas chambers

however they say that rabbi lazar and kamentestky are warning all shluchim that if they have done acts like this they should leave very queitly.

Another mass exodus of Soviet Jews.

Can we please cut the jokes on this very serious matter.

ah-pee-chorus-Madoff STOLE and HURT people and those people rightfully so demanded justice.It is also the governments job to hand justice to criminals.
This person didn't hurt anyone with his actions (beside his wife which is no ones business).He did NOT abuse kids like others that you say that a video would of helped.
If you cant see how low it is by being delighted with this then YOU are lower then i thought.I suppose this is what being an atheist is all about.Forget about that you don't believe in the Talmud where numerous times it says that nothing worse then defaming a person.Where are your non-Torah morals,sir?
YOU can twist it any way you want but delighting in THIS is outrageous disgusting and shameful.

Can't wait for the video of what went on in the Oval Office during the Clinton years. I of course, the Clinton managed to hold onto his job and his family. A spiritual leader is held to a higher standard, and it seems he was fired. Posting the video now just seems in bad taste, pardon the pun. Of course, the FM is so desperate for hits on it site to attract ads that it even considering posting a video of the blogger masurbating while watching this per, and but his mother walking into the garage in the middle.

Could this be how the baby dick sucker caught herpes?

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

----------------------

FailedMessiah.com is a reader supported website.

Thank you for your generous support!

----------------------

----------------------

----------------------

Please Scroll Down Toward The Bottom Of This Page For More Search Options, For A List Of Recent Posts, And For Comments Rules

----------------------

----------------------

Recent Posts

----------------------

Tip Jar

Gelt Is Good!

Tip Jar

FailedMessiah.com is a reader supported website. Please click the Donate button now to contribute.

Thank you for your generous support!

Tip Jar

Gelt Is Good!

Tip Jar

-------------------------

Comment Rules

  • 1. No anonymous comments.

    2. Use only one name or alias and stick with that.

    3. Do not use anyone else's name or alias.

    4. Do not sockpuppet.

    5. Try to argue using facts and logic.

    6. Do not lie.

    7. No name-calling, please.

    8. Do not post entire articles or long article excerpts.

    ***Violation of these rules may lead to the violator's comments being edited or his future comments being banned.***

Older Posts Complete Archives

Search FailedMessiah

Lijit Search

----------------------

FailedMessiah.com is a reader supported website.

Thank you for your generous support!

----------------------

----------------------

----------------------

FailedMessiah.com in the Media

RSS Feed

Blog Widget by LinkWithin