« Diaspora Orthodox Converts Will Now Be Recognized By Israel | Main | Video: Lawsuit Filed Against Kiryas Joel »

June 14, 2011

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

David

To A_H... dude, chill out. I think she was suffering enough from the harassing e-mails from clowns like you.

Gefilte Fish

To American Hater,

Is it nice to talk about your mother that way?

Adam Neira

To american_hater,

Your words are disgusting. Don't ever call a woman those words again. Every woman has a true self of purity, innocence and freedom. Male use, abuse and objectification of woman has been going on since year dot. The schechina does not lie in a small black box. It rests in the soul of every person.

Dr. Dave

sorry should read shel yad

Dr. Dave

She has the hel yad wrapped sephardic style.

american_hater

dirty whore.. i hope she suffers

pierre

Why so many comments in amazement that she has them in the boxes??? I think it is quite obvious she left them in on purpose - just as she also doesn't have it wrapped on her arm correctly, NOR is the Rosh placed on her head properly.

masortiman

"If it was good enough for Rashi's daughters, it's good enough for her."

hear, hear!

masortiman

"(BTW, it seems like non-religious women love putting on tefilin (reform, conservative, kneset staff etc if only men would be as eager... :))"


the only masorti women I know who put on tefilin (other than as part of their Bat Mitzvah ceremony) are quite "religious". The non religious ones skip morning minyan, like their male counterparts.

masortiman

"The ultra-observant will scream blue murder that a woman is daring to wear tfillin. Whilst the traditional/secular crowd will be laughing at the faux-piousness of the Hasidim."

My daughter wears tfillin as do several of her female friends. So do several women at my shul.

Ms Finkel can certainly keep wearing tfillin. I would advise her to learn the correct brachot, and to begin to daven every day. There are some really nice Masorti shuls in yerushaliyim that would welcome her. She could even join Women of the Wall.

I note that she seems to have assumed the texts did not themselves come from Masorti Jews. I know that I think her wearing tfillin WILL help bring redemption.

Adam Neira

This episode is a Pandora ’s Box, excuse the phylacteries based pun. The ultra-observant will scream blue murder that a woman is daring to wear tfillin. Whilst the traditional/secular crowd will be laughing at the faux-piousness of the Hasidim. What this episode does raise is the very important question...

Can the 613 Mitzvot be rated in order of importance ?

Two possibilities :

(a) It is possible to explain the relative importance of all the Mitzvot codified by Maimonides.

(b) They are all equal but are not all being fulfilled because the Holy Land is not ready yet, but good Jews should perform as many of the Mitzvot as possible.

Some fascinating questions are raised by this episode. Is the texters urging justified because they are attempting to raise the spiritual level of fellow Jews ? Is the woman being justifiably provocative to prick the pompous balloon of the obsessively observant ?

P.S. Did you know that the Rambam left out many Mitzvot contained in the Pentateuch ? i.e. The one about carrying a paddle outside the camp.

Yoel Mechanic

>>transgressed the prohibition of women wearing tefillin (or at least if they do wear them, it automatically becomes a life-long committment).

What?? what prohibition?? what committment(sic)?? There is no need to spread misinformation.

Reuven

She made her point. I doubt that her point would've been any more effective had she worn the tefillin "correctly".

Reuven

Harold Camping might've inspired the Knesset tefillin phone call prank...

OMG

Posted by: Alex | June 14, 2011 at 06:55 PM

I guess you would not recognize a joke even if it were served on a silver platter.

FirstGenerationBavarianAmerican

Hmmm....7 AM Jerusalem time is about the time Harold Camping finishes with his radio broadcast. You think the messages stopped the night Harold Camping suffered a stroke?

ah-pee-chorus

what a great move!!

Man from Jewland

HAHAH She really missed the point, she put on the cover boxes not tefillin itself!

Man from Jewland, hoping to visit America soon!

Alex

If [sic] would be more interesting if she had on only a bikini Posted by: OMG | June 14, 2011 at 04:22 PM

This woman found a clever and effective way of communicating to some pests (they were asked to desist). Why, in the process, should she demean herself and the tefillin? I guess she's not a hater like you.

larry

Is she actually wearing real Tefilin? from the picture it seems like they re the "outside" boxes - the ones you put on for protections after taking off the Tefilin.

(BTW, it seems like non-religious women love putting on tefilin (reform, conservative, kneset staff etc if only men would be as eager... :))

Shlomo

She seems to have gone out of her way not to have put on tefillin - she left the boxes on and the straps are reversed from the shel Rosh and she didn't wind the straps on her arm. She might not want to start putting on tefillin for the rest of her life as noted above

anuran

Good start. Should have been wearing just tefillin and a strategically placed tallis

bob

religious zealot idiots are destroying our whole planet

Teitelbaum

Look what she did?

The Moshiach will now have to be a Female and a Blonde.

Or Schnierson will have to be the redeemer from inside his coffin, because she didn't take the Tifilin out of its box.

David

Interesting idea, but she forgot to take the protective boxes off... Perhaps then, she hasn't really transgressed the prohibition of women wearing tefillin (or at least if they do wear them, it automatically becomes a life-long committment).

Yochanan Lavie

If it was good enough for Rashi's daughters, it's good enough for her.

OMG

If would be more interesting if she had on only a bikini

The comments to this entry are closed.

Failed messiah was established and run in 2004 by Mr. Shmarya (Scott)Rosenberg. The site was acquired by Diversified Holdings, Feb 2016.
.
We thank Mr. Rosenberg for his efforts on behalf of the Jewish Community

.

Comment Rules

  1. No anonymous comments.
  2. Use only one name or alias and stick with that.
  3. Do not use anyone else's name or alias.
  4. Do not sockpuppet.
  5. Try to argue using facts and logic.
  6. Do not lie.
  7. No name-calling, please.
  8. Do not post entire articles or long article excerpts.
***Violation of these rules may lead to the violator's comments being edited or his future comments being banned.***

Search this site with Google:

6a00d83451b71f69e201b8d1656462970c-250wi

FailedMessiah.com in the Media