« Brooklyn Rabbi's Son Accused Of Sexual Abuse Ordered To Stay Away From Sisters As Father, Brother Hide Out In Israel | Main | Explaining Chabad: How Did A Small Hasidic Court Become The Worldwide Face Of Judaism? »

December 04, 2010

Haredi Interior Minister Denies Responsibility For Israel's Lack Of Firefighting Resources

Eli Yishai 2 Eli Yishai, who is responsible for the country's firefighting services, contends that he did much to improve them.

Israel Carmel Brush Fire Ynet

Interior minister denies responsibility for lack of firefighting resources
Eli Yishai, who is responsible for the country's firefighting services, contends that he did much to improve them.

The Interior Minister, Shas leader Eli Yishai, responded on Saturday evening for the first time to criticism leveled at him for the performance of the country's firefighting services, which fall under his purview, in the massive fire burning through the Carmel region of northern Israel.

The minister emphasized in an interview with Channel 2 throughout his political career, there was no issue that he dealt with more than the firefighting services in Israel, which are, in his words, in a "catastrophic condition."

"I am happy to be interrogated and I requested an investigation commission to bring the truth to light," Yishai said. "I wrote letters and warned about the situation. I told Netanyahu that I will not vote with the government in non-confidence votes on this issue, if they come up."

Yishai stated, "I did a lot, and as a result of my struggle… I brought a hundred million shekels after eight to ten years, and I asked for more."

The interior minister gave examples that he contends prove his commitment to the issue of firefighting. "Seven years ago, when Ariel Sharon was prime minister, they made a decision to cancel firefighting aircraft, and I was the only one that voted against it."

Yishai also said that last year he requested and recommended that firefighting be transferred to the authority of the Interior Security Ministry.

Responding to a query of whether he was considering quitting his post, Yishai responded, "I didn't call for an inquiry for nothing, and it's no accident that even firefighters have been saying that since I arrived [to this position], the money has started to arrive. When the committee is formed and conducts a proper inquiry, it will all become clear and the truth will see the light."

Yishai continued, commending the performance of Prime Minister Netanyahu and Public Security Minister Yitzhak Aharonovitch. He attacked the media, claiming that they covered his comments regarding foreign workers and stipends for religious students, but although "there was no issue that I commented on more than firefighting, there is no record of this because it didn't interest the media." 

Ynet's report:

Yishai: I tried to increase firefighters' budget
Interior minister responds to criticism over firefighting services' unpreparedness for deadly Carmel blaze, accuses his predecessors of 'failing to act'
Roni Sofer • Ynet

Interior Minister Eli Yishai, who is in charge of Israel's firefighting services, responded to criticism Saturday following a wildfire in the Carmel region which claimed the lives of 41 people.

Yishai said he was not trying to shirk responsibility and had called for the establishment of a commission of inquiry into the disaster. He accused his predecessors of "failing to act", as opposed to him.

"I'm not evading responsibility," he said. "I've been acting ever since I took office. I have been the interior minister for less than two years."

Yishai told Ynet that a commission of inquiry "must provide the answers".

"I am responsible for the Interior Ministry and the firefighting services," he said, "but I will wait for the investigation committee's conclusions and do what it says."

He said he had tried to increase the firefighting services' budget. "We did whatever we could to add aid to the firefighting services, but the government makes the decisions in the end. I've had accomplishments too, but in the end we only got NIS 100 million (about $28 million) out of the NIS 500 million ($138 million) we asked for.

"I spoke to all relevant elements on this issue. Unfortunately, when I reached the Interior Ministry the equipment's condition was not good. I demanded that equipment be purchased. Unfortunately, the budget isn't big enough," he said.
Ministers: Yishai will never resign

The finger pointed over at Yishai is not rocking the government – and it is unlikely that Yishai will resign. Senior ministers said Saturday that despite public calls for his resignation, "nothing will happen."

One minister said Yishai is already busy "covering his behind," explaining at every opportunity that he is not responsible. "Nothing like resignation will happen," the minister said. "Who cares if he resigns or not?"

"He will never resign, and anyway you can't resign over everything," said a source who knows Yishai well. "Resignation is not a solution in his opinion, and he will never resign over anything. However, it must be noted that right now they are doing him an injustice. The Finance Ministry controlled all the ministries, and it determines everything. It's true that Yishai could have insisted more if he had wanted, but the Finance Ministry has people deciding what happens in each ministry."

Experienced ministers noted that people could be found to take the blame. "Ronnie Bar-On and Meir Sheetrit were also interior ministers, but in the end it comes down to some clerk at the Finance Ministry who didn't agree to allocate the requested sums to the firefighting services," they said. "This is a familiar story, and in the end they'll find that someone stuck something in some ministry, and that'll be the end of it."

It is not yet clear whether Yishai's call for a national investigating committee will be answered, since Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu opposes such a move. However, ministers said the prime minister is aware he must set up some kind of investigation. "A national investigation committee is unnecessary, and is mainly a source of profit for lawyers," they said, adding that recommendations from any investigation would be clear: The firefighting services should be transferred to the authority of the Ministry for Internal Security.

A senior minister suggested a new firefighting law be passed rapidly which would transfer the authority of the interior minister to the internal security minister. "The prime minister must act quickly to move forward," he said. "A firefighting law is what's needed now."

Another minister who is also a cabinet member said he did not think a national investigation committee would be set up, though of course there would be an investigation. He noted there was also the state comptroller's own investigation which would soon be released.

However, government ministers over the weekend expressed their satisfaction with the prime minister's behavior during the crisis, saying "he managed to realize it was a mega-event. He knows how to do the right show for the public, like Sunday's government session in Tirat Carmel, which is a total pose. Friday's cabinet meeting was also a show. We didn't vote on anything. It seems Netanyahu just wanted to be seen in public with his ministers. They showed us a lovely presentation and aircraft. We saw photos. It was nice but nothing more than that."

Meanwhile, the state comptroller will release a report on the firefighting services during the next fortnight. This report was supposed to be included in a special monitoring report released following the Second Lebanon War, on the functioning of the home front on security issues.

In 2007 a state comptroller's report noted the firefighting services were a weak point in rescue operations. But despite this report, government ministries did not follow the recommendations and not only was the situation not corrected, but it deteriorated during the last three years. The coming report, described as extremely grave, exposes new faults and the state comptroller is expected to write that fundamental changes are required throughout the firefighting services, as well as new equipment and increased manpower.


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.


That explains it all! If he were secular it would have never had happened. Damn it!

Less money to kollel bums and more money for firefighters.

Yochanan, Yes. This. Absolutely. Or make the bochurs pay for their kollel by working as firefighters, laborers on public works projects and similar after they get out of the Army

Pray in one hand. Crap in the other. See which fills up first.


His responsibility
His watch
His policies
His blame

He needs to go

Eli Yishai was only able to work within his budget. The entire cabinate was aware of the lack of preparedness beforehand as well as the Knesset. This was everybodie's fault.

A quote from Reuters.com.
Slightly off topic but worthwhile nonetheless.

'Help from unexpected quarters came from the occupied West Bank, where Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas dispatched three firetrucks and crew to the Haifa area, after a rare and friendly telephone chat with Netanyahu on Saturday.

An Israeli statement said Abbas had expressed condolences to for the Israelis killed in the fire on Thursday. Most were prison guard trainees who had arrived to help evacuate 500 inmates from the Damon facility near Haifa.'

This idiot would rather send money to Haredi yeshivas, while Israel burns

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment



FailedMessiah.com is a reader supported website.

Thank you for your generous support!




Please Scroll Down Toward The Bottom Of This Page For More Search Options, For A List Of Recent Posts, And For Comments Rules


Recent Posts


FailedMessiah.com is a reader supported website. Please click the Donate button now to contribute.

Thank you for your generous support!


Comment Rules

  • 1. No anonymous comments.

    2. Use only one name or alias and stick with that.

    3. Do not use anyone else's name or alias.

    4. Do not sockpuppet.

    5. Try to argue using facts and logic.

    6. Do not lie.

    7. No name-calling, please.

    8. Do not post entire articles or long article excerpts.

    ***Violation of these rules may lead to the violator's comments being edited or his future comments being banned.***

Older Posts Complete Archives

Search FailedMessiah


FailedMessiah.com is a reader supported website.

Thank you for your generous support!



FailedMessiah.com in the Media

RSS Feed

Blog Widget by LinkWithin