« RUBASHKIN TAKES THE STAND | Main | Judaism And Healthcare Reform: GOP Bill Penalizes Sick And Elderly »

November 06, 2009


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.


As if there wasn't enough on our plate already.

A. Nuran

It's not about modesty. It's about control. Charedism, a totalitarian offshoot of Judaism, is simply following the classic pattern. This includes absolute control over anything connected to sexuality and increasingly crazy restrictions on all aspects of women's lives.

Mr. Apikorus

What would happen if a similar protest occured with Monsey Trails?

In this country, discrimination on account of sex is strictly illegal with regard to public accomodations. Yet Monsey Trails, with its segregation of male and female passengers, and its curtain separating them, continues.

Non-violent civil disobedience demonstrations against Monsey Trails, in which men and women sit together, and refuse to leave if asked by the bus driver or by other passengers, are long overdue.


I have an idea why not tell the rebbies we agree but the men should go to the back and lets see how they respond


They are turning into Moslems. They may even outdo the Moslems if this is not stopped.


If charedim want to make their women sit in the back of the bus I have no problem with it.
However, since they are treating their women like cattle, they should be careful just to make to help them get them back up if they topple over from their load, and allow them to work without a muzzle, so they can eat as they work if they get hungry.

A. Nuran

Reader, they're turning into Wahabis and Talibanis. There are millions upon millions of Muslims all over the world who aren't like that. By the same token most Jews don't do this kind of crap. But the fundamentalist/totalitarian strain is present and growing in both religions as it is in Christianity.

A. Nuran

Critical Minyan, I've got plenty of problems with "them" forcing "their" women to do anything. Nobody should forced to act like a second class citizen or be expected to obey orders from random strangers on fear of humiliation or assault.

And decent people should not tolerate, let alone financially support, a culture which permits people to treat half the human race like something less than human.

Yes, I get the joke. Yes, it's funny. But as much as my aberrant lifestyle offends them, theirs puts me in mind of Sir Charles Napier when he addressed the custom of suttee.
He said

"You say that it is your custom to burn widows. Very well. We also have a custom: when men burn a woman alive, we tie a rope around their necks and we hang them. Build your funeral pyre; beside it, my carpenters will build a gallows. You may follow your custom. And then we will follow ours.

If they cannot be induced to stop treating people like things they should expect to be so treated in return.


A Nuran, brilliant comment. We need to organize freedom riders, Israeli men and woman to go on buses and ride together. Video tape is possible, humiliate them. Make Israeli society see the cancer in their midst.

Hometown Postville

One simple question: Why are the Haredi so afraid of women????????

Yochanan Lavie

And now, some Beatle Torah:

Roll up.
Roll up for the Mehadrin Tzuris.
Roll up.
Roll up for the Mehadrin Tzuris.

Roll up.
And that's an invitation.
Roll up for the Mehadrin Tzuris.
Roll up.
Women's humiliation.
Roll up for the Mehadrin Tzuris.

The Tragical Mehadrin Tzuris
Is waiting to take you oy vey.
Waiting to take you oy vey.

Roll up.
Roll up for the Mehadrin Tzuris.
Roll up.
Roll up for the Mehadrin Tzuris.

Roll up.
We got the mechitza you need.
Roll up for the Mehadrin Tzuris.
Roll up.
Mega chumrot guaranteed.
Roll up for the Mehadrin Tzuris.

The Tragical Mehadrin Tzuris
Is hoping to take Judaism away.
Hoping to take it away.

(Mehadrin Tzuris..)
Ah.. The Tragical Mehadrin Tzuris.
Roll up.
Roll up for the Mehadrin Tzuris.

Roll up.
And that's an invocation.
Roll up for the Mehadrin Tzuris.
Roll up.
Of powers above the nation.
Roll up for the Mehadrin Tzuris.

The Magical Mehadrin Tzuris
Is coming to take you oy vey.
Coming to take you oy vey.

The Tragical Mehadrin Tzuris
Is dying to take you avek.
Dying to take you avek.
Take you to heck.


What a paradise we have made for the Jews in Israel!! How good it must be there. Remind me to stay far away from the place. How Israeli must pity me, a poor American Jew who must defer to and be considerate of women every day, even as the stick their seductive and wanton bodies all over the place.
Yeah, remind me to stay far the hell away from Israel. It sounds like everything any sane Jew would try to avoid. With outside danger, to boot, with a dispossessed majority wanting their stolen lands and homes back. Whose bright idea was this anyway?


Freedom rides for women in Israel? Go ahead, make yourself a laughingstock in front of the world. Please, be my guest.
Look, Israeli society cannot be other than it is. In order for Israel to survive, an high degree of aggressive defensiveness is incumbent on everybody there. Which, it only natural, makes them all crazy. It's one thing to be driven crazy by persecution, but it's entirely another to drive yourself crazy (and try to make your children crazy) because you've put yourself into an untenable situation.
Any Israel, good luck de-segregating the buses.
And the rest of the world won't have any trouble figuring out why haredi men are so afraid of women. I'm sure they will draw the right conclusions.


Ah yes, by all means bring video cameras to film the women on the buses, it'll go very well with the films on how you treat the Palistinians.

Tarfon Steinerman

Sounds good, but I have an idea for a Mehadrin MinHamehadrin line: Men in the front, underaged boys in the back. Those are the real souls we need to protect.


This term modesty is a misnomer.
A subset of charedis are gay and thus are sickened by any thought of touching women or seeing female skin.

That explanation accounts for all of their funny laws.


I didn't say they were becoming radical. What they are practicing more and more is not "fundamentalist Judaism" but an "islamized Judaism". They are Jewish heretics. They are changing Judaism into a branch of Islam. I've also seen in print that some of them openly admire Muslims for their "values" and family life.

a Rider

@MR. Apikores,

I sat with my wife almost every day that I would commute on Monsey Trails in the Ladies Section. When a shpitzle would mistakenly believe that she could not sit on the same side as a man, I politely explained it to her.

A. Nuran

Hotspur, I would support any such efforts, but I have neither the time nor the money to go to Israel. And since my wife is not Jewish I have only a theoretical horse in that race. I wouldn't ask her to risk going to jail on behalf of someone else's tribe.

Notice that I say "go to jail" not "get hurt or killed". I rather suspect it would be the Tallitbanis who would end up bleeding.

A. Nuran

Mooser, your amateur attempts at psychoanalyzing The Perfidious Zioninst Jew are as pathetic as they are transpartent. Suffice it to say that no Arab state, let alone the repulsive brand of death-worshipping thug which currently serves as Hamas and Fatah's leaders treats its own people half as well.

Jack Schitt, Esq.

The R' Moshe T'shuva had to do with buses in America, not in Israel. It is dubious to use it as a source to say that mixing is acceptable on Haredi - not non-Jewish NYC - bus services. The two situations are far from analogous and arguably R' Moshe would not have said the same thing where separate seating could be made available because of the demand of Haredi clientele.

Mr. Apikorus

A Rider:

Good for you, and your wife.

To your knowledge, has any driver (or passenger) attempted to throw someone off (or under) the bus for defying the separation of sexes rules?


Mooser the idiot writes: "Ah yes, by all means bring video cameras to film the women on the buses, it'll go very well with the films on how you treat the Palistinians."

First of all Mooser this article has nothing to do with Palestinians. Second please shut your putrid mouth.


While I am sure what Naomi Ragen says is true and I agree with her bringing suit the actual situation in Jerusalem is not as bad as people posting seem to think.

I am not haredi but live in a predominantly haredi neighborhood and take buses almost every day. No neighborhood in Jerusalem is so isolated that a bus line only runs in it; that is, probably almost every bus line runs through different kinds of neighborhoods. While it is true that the drivers are no help, and some are a hindrance, being confident and if needed aggressive shuts most of the jerks up. For the most part I had more trouble when I was trying to be polite, American style.

That being said, the haredim pushing this separation are totally out of line. They do not have a leg to stand on either legally or halachically or based on just plain manners and human consideration. No one should have to sit in segregated sections on public conveyances. This modesty thing is very bizarre and totally out of hand.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)

Search this site with Google:

Comment Rules

  1. No anonymous comments.
  2. Use only one name or alias and stick with that.
  3. Do not use anyone else's name or alias.
  4. Do not sockpuppet.
  5. Try to argue using facts and logic.
  6. Do not lie.
  7. No name-calling, please.
  8. Do not post entire articles or long article excerpts.
***Violation of these rules may lead to the violator's comments being edited or his future comments being banned.***

FailedMessiah.com in the Media