« Dov Hikind and Child Sexual Abuse | Main | Satmar Violence »

January 15, 2007

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Lubavitcher Rebbe on these issues click here to read more

B"H
(to read the whole Sicha click the link bellow)
A review of the various codifiers through the centuries will turn up the interesting fact that generally the Chachmei Sefard (Oriental and Spanish Rabbis) ruled that yibum was given preference over chalitzah while the Ashkenazic rabbis ruled that chalitzah is first choice.

Another related subject in which we find the same ongoing difference of opinion concerns the permissibility of marrying more than one wife. Among Ashkenazim the cherem (ban and prohibition) of Rabbeinu Gershon (Me'or Hagolah) is strictly adhered to in all religious circles while Sefardic Jews never accepted the cherem and up to modern times continue to practice polygamy in Sefardic countries.

We may suggest an explanation of this dichotomy in correlation to the general philosophy covering marriage as expressed by the Rambam:

The sensible course is for man first to choose an occupation that will give him a livelihood, then buy himself a home; and after that take a wife; as it is said "and what man is there that has planted a vineyard and not redeemed it...what man is there that has built a new house and has not dedicated it? ...and what man is there that has betrothed a woman and not taken her?" (Devorim [Deuteronomy] 20:5-7) But the foolish first marry, then if one of this sort can afford it, he purchases a house; and last of all, towards the end of his life, he sets about seeking a trade or lives on charity. Thus it is said in the imprecations: "A wife you shall betroth...a house you shall build...a vineyard you shall plant" (Devorim 28:30); that is, all your activities shall be in the reverse order of what they should be.

(Laws of Moral Disposition and Ethical Conduct 5:11)

It is clear that the Rambam predicates the institution of marriage on the ability to support a wife and family.

How have Jews prospered during the long years of exile? We have seen a tangible difference between the condition in Sephardic lands among the Moslems as compared to Ashkenazic lands among Christians. The golus among the Edomites (Christians) has been considerably worse. This may depend on the fact that the Rambam rules that the Yishmaelites (Moslems) believe in G-d while Christians are actually idolaters. For this reason the golus among the Edomites has been so much more fearful.

With this in mind the Sages of Ashkenaz have felt that the pressure of the exile precluded a Jew from having more than one wife or consummating the levirate marriage. In Sefardi lands where life was easier the restrictions did not apply.

May G-d grant that speedily we will see the end of both the exile of Edom and Yishmael. "For so many years have passed since all the predestined times have passed," and we can only say "How long!"

Certainly, G-d will fulfill our request and redeem us from the golus with our youth and elders, sons and daughters, with our complete Torah and mitzvos, to our Holy Land, Yerushalayim the Holy City and the Bais HaMikdash. So may it be, speedily and truly in our time.

an observer

One of the accepted reasons for the Nazi terror is that the religious Jews demanded nadden, a dowry. Many women were left single and cried bitterly to Hashem. No less an authoritative journal, The Jewish Observer, mentioned this explanation. Perhaps this is why it isn't so bad in the US.

Yochanan Lavie

"One of the accepted reasons for the Nazi terror is that the religious Jews demanded nadden, a dowry."

I don't accept it. There is no possible why the Jews, the vast majority innocent, deserved the Holocaust. It defies explanation.

chief doofis

If a girl, and her parents, are so moronic that they want one of those freeloaders, they deserve whatever they get.

There are many young men who are G-dfearing and hard working people, who can make these girls happy. Most of these girls have never seen the inside of a Gemara and have no clue as to what goes on in a Beth Medrash. They only do what they are doing because of the propaganda issued by the ESTABLISHMENT.

Marry a nice frum boy, let him come home from WORK every day and spend a few hours learning. You will be a much happier prson.

Isa

What happens when the new groomhas children and has to spend $$$$$$ to marry of his daughters? Simple: What goes around ,comes around.

chief doofis

Why do you think the CITY of Bnei B'rak is bankrupt?

The Orthodox world is collapsing on itself like a red star. Too many people are producing too little, and spending too much!!

Tuition for elementary/secondary schooling in Yeshivas is rising at an unprecedented rate. Too much of the limited resources of the Orthodox community is geared toward "higher" education (sic!), and the accompanying "bank-kvetching", while the needs of our precious little ones are overlooked. If we don't restrict Kollel to serve only the select few, who will be carefully groomed (fat chance!!) to serve as educators, jurists, and pulpit Rabbis (LOL), Orthodoxy will wither on the vine.

JewishCynic

I see positive in this post. Haredim have adopted many of the practices of closed off cultures, the dowry is just one of them. But it's good to hear that in this case "Important rabbis are now supporting the parents’ point of view and calling for an end to the economic madness." I'll grasp onto any straw of hope in that haredi madness!
This situation does bring to mind the over the top Bar/Bat mitzvah situation in the US particularly in the Conservative Reform and M.O. worlds. The pressure on parents to drain their finances to put on that black-tie/country club affair is tremendous. And what connection to mitvah is there when you have a Titanic themed affair or hire Aerosmith to perform. Those groups rabbis need to speak out too (but of course the guys putting on the $1mil bar mitzvahs are also big temple donors...).

chief doofis

The left wing Rabbis who don't complain about the "million" dollar Bar Mitzvas are afraid to have the money donated to Jewish education. Too much education, might make the kid observant, and the Rabbi will lose his sinecure.

The right wing Rabbis are afraid that hey will lose their sinecure if the populace gets acquainted with the real world out there.

The middle of the road is screwed from both ends!!

gross

At least the parents who throw lavish Bar/Bat Mitzvahs aren't doing so on someone else's dime. I still agree with you though. It's outrageous.

Yochanan Lavie

"The middle of the road is screwed from both ends!!"

I agree. It's about time to stop kvetching and start something new. That's my main complaint about this blog- it rightfully points out the negative, but offers no alternatives.

Neandershort

The "solution" is simple. You go to America and collect for "poor Talmudic schlars in Israel." Parasitism begets schnorring. Or the parents can wise up, put their foot down and just say no. Go out and work for a living like you undertake to do in the ketuba. Remember that ketuba? I will work for you, I will support you. . . .?

YUGUY

Unfotunately, it is not the fault of middle of the road Orthodoxy that it is screwed, and the other 'sides' will not bother respecting the middle. Therefore, there are many solutions to the problem, but these solutions lie on the side of right or left wing judaism, and they will refuse to help those of us they despise. Do you have an alternative that can help centerist orthodoxy that doesn't require help from the 'sides?'

Yochanan Lavie

Sorry, YU Guy, I am searching for a solution myself. Maybe Chovevei Torah and/or The Union For Traditional Judaism. But I'm not sure those guys have what it takes.

Neo-Conservaguy

Centerist Orthodoxy is proposed as a "middle" position? Well, that's today's healthy laugh for me, YUGUY.

Viviennemar

My question is, what are the children of those currently studying going to do? If the parents become so overburdened that they cannot leave a legacy to their children and the fathers/husbands aren't making any progress towards a career that provides a sustainable salary, aren't they dooming their children and grandchildren?

chief doofis

Frankly, my dear, they don't give a damn!!

I think we should learn from the great Rabbi Chanina bar Chama. From the Chabad.org website, "Rabbi Chanina did not wish to make the Torah "an axe to dig with." He did not wish to use his knowledge of Torah as a means to obtain a livelihood, or honor and the like. He began to deal in honey, and his business flourished. He became a rich man, and the first thing he did was to build a Torah academy in his town Tzippori entirely from his own money."

chief doofis

Dear neoconservaguy;

Yuguy and his centrist Orthodoxy do represent the middle of the road.He stands for halacha sans add-ons that are merely there to artificially divide groups of Jews. What was considered satisfactory amongst the most observant Jews 40 years ago, can get you thrown out of Yeshiva today.

Where do you find centrist Orthodoxy to be intolerant BEYOND the realm of Halacha?

Shmuel Beis

Notice how the opposite of "god fearing" is a "guy who works"

chief doofis

Dear Shmuel Bais;

If you carefully read my post, you will see that I recommended that girls look for G-d fearing, hard working young men. These two concepts are not opposed to each other. Isn't it funny that King David started out as a shepherd, Elisha did, Moshe did, Obviously all three Avot did. Yirmiyahi was taking care of his vineyard, Nechemia was an aide at the Persian court. All of these personages must have been G-d fearing, working people. No Biblical figure (ZIP, NADA, NINGUNO, KEN EINEM NIT) was recorded by the Nevi'im as being in Kollel (KOILIL)!!

Read the large paragraph in the Shema. We are promised that if we behave ourselves, the grass will grow for our animals, the grapes will grow, the rain will fall, etc... It does not say YOUR SHVER WILL SUPPORT YOU!! (and it certainly doesn't mention food stamps and government programs!!)

Isa

I went to Ohr Samecha in 1985. I was taught a wife can work just so long as it is not out of the home. They viewed a wife who stayed home as the ideal. The rabbis there said the attraction to women in becoming religious was here was an avenue in which the women can realize the traditional way of life.

YUGUY

Thats unfortunate. Women can work wherever they want. And the phrase 'working out of the home' is very ambiguous, by the way.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)

Search this site with Google:

Comment Rules

  1. No anonymous comments.
  2. Use only one name or alias and stick with that.
  3. Do not use anyone else's name or alias.
  4. Do not sockpuppet.
  5. Try to argue using facts and logic.
  6. Do not lie.
  7. No name-calling, please.
  8. Do not post entire articles or long article excerpts.
***Violation of these rules may lead to the violator's comments being edited or his future comments being banned.***
6a00d83451b71f69e201b8d1656462970c-250wi

FailedMessiah.com in the Media